The Azerbaijan State News Agency

WORLD

How the World Bank breaks its promise to protect the poor

How the World Bank breaks its promise to protect the poor

Baku, April 17, AZERTAC

Since 2004 an estimated 3,350,449 people were forced from their homes, deprived of their land or had their livelihoods damaged because they lived in the path of a World Bank project, “publicintegrity.org” website reports.

For more than three decades, the World Bank has maintained a set of “safeguard” policies that it claims have brought about a more humane and democratic system of economic development.

Governments that borrow money from the bank can’t force people from their homes without warning. Families evicted to make way for dams, power plants or other big projects must be resettled and their livelihoods restored.

The bank’s commitment, it says, is to “do no harm” to people or the environment.

The World Bank has broken its promise.

Over the past decade the bank has regularly failed to enforce its rules, with devastating consequences for some of the poorest and most vulnerable people on the planet, an investigation by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (a project of the Center for Public Integrity), The Huffington Post and other media partners has found.

The World Bank often neglects to properly review projects ahead of time to make sure communities are protected and frequently has no idea what happens to people after they are removed. In many cases, it has continued to do business with governments that have abused their citizens, sending a signal that borrowers have little to fear if they violate the bank’s rules, according to current and former bank employees.

A team of more than 50 journalists from 21 countries spent nearly a year documenting the bank’s failure to protect people moved aside in the name of progress. The reporting partners analyzed thousands of World Bank records, interviewed hundreds of people and reported on the ground in Albania, Brazil, Ethiopia, Honduras, Ghana, Guatemala, India, Kenya, Kosovo, Nigeria, Peru, Serbia, South Sudan and Uganda.

In these countries and others, the investigation found, the bank’s lapses have hurt urban slum dwellers, hardscrabble farmers, impoverished fisherfolk, forest dwellers and indigenous groups — leaving them to fight for their homes, their land and their ways of life, sometimes in the face of intimidation and violence.

Between 2004 and 2013, the World Bank and its private sector lending arm, the International Finance Corp., have committed to lend $455 billion to bankroll nearly 7,200 projects in developing countries.

Over the same span, people affected by World Bank and IFC investments have lodged dozens of complaints with the lenders’ internal review panels, alleging the lenders and their borrowers had failed to live up to World Bank and IFC safeguard rules.

In Lagos, the World Bank’s ombudsman, the Inspection Panel, said bank management “fell short of protecting the poor and vulnerable communities against forceful evictions.” Bank officials should have paid better attention to what was going on in Badia East, the panel said, given Lagos authorities’ long history of bulldozing slums and forcing people from their homes.

One year after the evictions, the bank loaned Lagos authorities $200 million to support the state government’s budget.

The World Bank said it was “not a party to the demolition” and that it advised the Lagos government to negotiate with displaced people, leading to compensation for most of those who said they’d been harmed.

On India’s northwest coast, members of a historically oppressed Muslim community claim that heated water spewing from a coal-fueled power plant has depleted fish and lobster stocks in the once-fertile gulf where they make their living. The IFC loaned Tata Power, one of India’s largest companies, $450 million to help build the plant.

The U.S. and other global powers launched the World Bank at the end of World War II to promote development in countries torn by war and poverty. Member countries finance the bank and vote on whether to approve roughly $65 billion in annual loans, grants and other investments.

In 2014, the bank financed initiatives as varied as training for chicken farmers in Senegal and sewage system upgrades in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

World Bank President Kim said in March that the demand in struggling regions for infrastructure spending — to provide clean water, electricity, medical care and other vital needs — will mean the bank will finance an increasing number of big projects likely to remove people from their land, or disrupt their livelihoods.

The World Bank also put out a five-and-a-half-page “action plan” that it said would improve its oversight of resettlement.

“We must and will do better,” said David Theis, a World Bank spokesman, in response to the reporting team’s questions.

Yet even as it promised quick reforms to its procedures, the bank has proposed sweeping changes to the policies that underlie them. The bank is now in the middle of a rewrite of its safeguards policy that will set the bank’s course for decades to come.

Some current and former World Bank officials warn that the proposed revisions will further undermine the bank’s commitment to protecting the people it was created to serve. The latest draft of the bank’s new policy, released last July, would give governments more room to sidestep the bank’s standards and make decisions about whether local populations need protecting, they say.

“I am saddened to see now that pioneering policy achievements of the bank are being dismantled and downgraded,” said Michael Cernea, a former high-ranking bank official who oversaw the bank’s resettlement protections for nearly two decades. “The poorest and most powerless will pay the price.”

The bank says it has listened to the feedback and will release a revised draft with “the strongest, most state-of-the-art environmental and social safeguards.”

Share news on social media

Follow us on social network

President Ilham Aliyev participated in the High Level Segment of the 15th Petersberg Climate Dialogue

Aramco and FIFA announce global partnership

President of Azerbaijan: A country rich in natural resources, particularly oil and gas, should be at forefront of those addressing issues of climate change

President Ilham Aliyev: COP29 will allow us to engage countries of the Global South

President: We do not only need to organize COP29 well but also to deliver good results

President of Azerbaijan: Election of Azerbaijan as COP29 host by unanimous decision is a big honor for us

President Ilham Aliyev: Our oil and gas will be needed for many more years including European markets

Foreign Ministry: Resolution adopted by European Parliament openly misrepresents human rights situation in Azerbaijan

President Ilham Aliyev: As the host country of COP29, Azerbaijan is in active phase of preparation

China's homegrown brain-machine interface system unveiled at Zhongguancun Forum

Some US troops set to depart Chad, at least temporarily

Meeting of SCO defense ministers to start in Astana today

Russian cosmonauts complete spacewalk two hours ahead of schedule

Ancient Giant Tortoise Fossils Found In Colombian Andes

Speaker of Azerbaijan’s Milli Majlis embarks on official visit to Montenegro

Man City hammer Brighton 4-0 to be hot on English leaders Arsenal's trail

Venice introduces entrance fee for touristic old city

Azerbaijan’s Defense Ministry: Wave-2024 joint tactical exercise ends VIDEO

Oil prices surge in global markets

Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan discuss prospects for development of military cooperation

Azeri Light crude dips to $88

China’s Shenzhou-18 crew arrive at Tiangong space station

Germany expresses readiness to support Azerbaijan in COP29

Azerbaijan relocates 140 more residents to Fuzuli city VIDEO

Azerbaijani writer awarded Chingiz Aitmatov medal

President Ilham Aliyev embarked on working visit to Germany VIDEO

Azerbaijani Speaker meets with Parliamentary Committee Chairs of Turkic States

China launches 3 astronauts to Tiangong space station on Shenzhou 18 mission

Press conference highlights outcomes of First Meeting of Committee Chairs of Turkic States’ Parliaments

Five short films to be shot about Wetlands on Northern Black Sea Coast

Azerbaijani judoka advances to final of 2024 European Championships in Croatia

Milli Majlis of Azerbaijan responds to the European Parliament’s resolution

® Kapital Bank participated in Azerbaijan’s banking mission’s inaugural visit to the United States

® Age of innovations kicks off with Bakcell!

Presidents Ilham Aliyev and Sadyr Zhaparov toured Shahbulag Fortress in Aghdam VIDEO

Presidents of Azerbaijan and Kyrgyzstan attended ground-breaking ceremony for secondary school of Khydyrly village in Aghdam VIDEO

LG Electronics’ operating profit falls 10.8 pct in Q1

Presidents of Azerbaijan and Kyrgyzstan visited Aghdam Conference Center VIDEO

Euronews TV channel airs reportage on Azerbaijan’s Port of Baku

President Ilham Aliyev and President Sadyr Zhaparov attended opening of Aghdam Juma Mosque after restoration VIDEO

Amy Adams to star in drama ‘At the Sea’ from ‘Pieces Of A Woman’ filmmakers Kornel Mundruczó & Kata Wéber

Presidents of Azerbaijan and Kyrgyzstan inspected ongoing works at Palace of Panahali Khan and Imarat complex in Aghdam VIDEO

Azerbaijani FIFA referee to control Panathinaikos vs Aris Greek Super League encounter

Press release of service of Deputy Prime Minister of the Republic of Azerbaijan Shahin Mustafayev

Azerbaijani rhythmic gymnasts to fight for glory in international tournament in Bulgaria

Azerbaijani taekwondo fighters to compete in Presidents Cup Europe G2

155 dead, 236 injured as torrential rains hit Tanzania

Russia confirms readiness to facilitate Azerbaijani-Armenian border demarcation - diplomat

Azerbaijan, Kyrgyzstan sign Memorandum of Understanding

Philippines grapples with measles, pertussis outbreaks: UNICEF

China welcomes progress made in Azerbaijan-Armenia normalization process

President of Kyrgyzstan Sadyr Zhaparov concludes his state visit to Azerbaijan

Presidents of Azerbaijan and Kyrgyzstan had joint dinner VIDEO

Azerbaijani gymnast into final of 2024 Men’s Artistic Europeans

More than 100 inmates escape after rain damages Nigerian prison

Human remains found in Khojaly district VIDEO

Presidents of Azerbaijan and Kyrgyzstan visited the city of Aghdam VIDEO

Presidents of Azerbaijan and Kyrgyzstan visited devastated areas of Fuzuli city and reviewed the city’s master plan VIDEO

US secretary of state lands in China on crucial visit

Azerbaijan showcases its tourism potential in Jordan

Tesla could start selling Optimus robots by the end of next year, Musk says

Egypt welcomes agreement between Azerbaijan and Armenia

Azerbaijan, Kyrgyzstan discuss digital transformation

Toyota fails to meet 10.1 mil. output target in FY 2023 amid scandals

Hungary eager to increase gas supply from Azerbaijan

NASA's Voyager 1 returns intelligible signal for 1st time in months

Azerbaijani film selected for Cannes Short Film Festival

Azerbaijan to pin hopes on seven judokas at European Championships Seniors Zagreb 2024

Atalanta beats 10-man Fiorentina 4-1 to reach Italian Cup final vs. Juventus

Foreign Ministry: Azerbaijan attaches great importance to cooperation with relevant UN human rights treaty bodies

Baku hosts First Meeting of Foreign Affairs Committee Chairs of Turkic States’ Parliaments

Iraqi President invited to COP29

Liverpool lose at Everton in derby, hurting their English Premier League title hopes

Trade turnover between Azerbaijan and Hungary increased by 40 percent, says minister

Oil prices surge in global markets

Azerbaijan's Minister of Labor and Social Protection of Population meets with Hungarian FM

Azerbaijan, Algeria discuss energy cooperation

Kyrgyz Cinema Days open in Baku

President of Kyrgyzstan Sadyr Zhaparov, who is on state visit to Azerbaijan, arrived in Fuzuli district VIDEO

Azerbaijani Army conducts command-staff exercises

Azerbaijani oil sells for $89.49

COP29 Presidency opens application process for national pavilions

International forum themed “COP29 and Green Vision for Azerbaijan” was held at ADA University
President Ilham Aliyev attended the forum

State reception was hosted in honor of President of Kyrgyzstan Sadyr Zhaparov VIDEO

® Bakcell is inviting the entire country to the concert at Boulevard

® Birbank Business’s special “Welcome” campaign for new customers

President Ilham Aliyev and President Sadyr Zhaparov attended unveiling ceremony of monument to Chingiz Aitmatov in Baku VIDEO

President Ilham Aliyev and President Sadyr Zhaparov made press statements VIDEO

Kyrgyz President Sadyr Zhaparov pays tribute to Azerbaijani martyrs

Kyrgyz President Sadyr Zhaparov pays respect to Great Leader Heydar Aliyev

Al Pacino, Dan Stevens to play troubled priests in exorcism horror ‘The Ritual’

US Congress members informed about Azerbaijan-Armenia peace process

Serb Member of Presidency of Bosnia and Herzegovina Željka Cvijanović invited to COP29

Azerbaijan-Hungary Energy Working Group convenes fourth meeting

AZERTAC hosts meeting with Uzbek journalists VIDEO

Court investigates business corruption accusation against wife of Spanish PM

`Kyrgyzstan will be third country involved in construction of a school in Karabakh`

Hungarian foreign minister to visit Azerbaijan

Türkiye rejects ‘one-sided’ statements on 1915 events

Azerbaijani rowers aim for 'medal rush' in Hungarian tournaments