The Azerbaijan State News Agency

POLITICS

International Institute for Peace: Armenia–Azerbaijan conflict ushered into a more dangerous and unstable period

Baku, August 7, AZERTAC

The Vienna-based International Institute for Peace (IIP) has published an article headlined “Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict ushered into a more dangerous and unstable period”.

Written by Ambassador and Chairman of the Center of Analysis of International Relations (AIR Center) Farid Shafiyev and Senior Advisor of the Center Vasif Huseynov, the article reads: “July 2020 marked one of the most intense escalations in the more than thirty-year-old conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan over the occupied Azerbaijani territories - Nagorno-Karabakh and seven surrounding regions. The sudden clashes, which occurred on July 12-14 on the state border between the two sides in the direction of the Tovuz region of Azerbaijan, geographically far from the occupied territories of Azerbaijan, resulted in the loss of up to 20 military servicemen on both sides. The recent historical background of these clashes and the developments following them demonstrate that the two conflicting countries have entered a period that is likely to be more dangerous and unstable for the peace and security of the region.

Violent dispute between Armenia and Azerbaijan broke out in the aftermath of the dissolution of the Soviet Union in late 1980s, though it had roots back in the Soviet period, when Armenians consistently sought to have the Nagorno-Karabakh region separated from Soviet Azerbaijan and unified with Soviet Armenia. After the break-up of the Soviet Union, Armenia launched a full-scale military operation against Azerbaijan in 1992-94, which resulted in the occupation of almost 20% of Azerbaijan’s internationally recognized territory. Notwithstanding the internationally mediated peace process since the ceasefire agreement established in May 1994, the two sides failed to reach a peace agreement. In the aftermath of the so-called Velvet Revolution of 2018, which brought Nikol Pashinyan to power in Armenia, a degree of optimism arrived at the negotiating table. In contrast to his predecessors, Prime Minister Pashinyan is not of Karabakh origin and is not associated with the war of the early 1990s. This was part of the reason why he was therefore expected to show more constructivism with regard to the negotiations brokered by the Minsk Group of the OSCE, co-chaired by Russia, the United States, and France.

There were indeed a number of positive developments at the beginning of Pashinyan’s rule. In late 2018, the leaders of Azerbaijan and Armenia agreed on the establishment of a telephone hotline between the military commanders for the first time, and in January 2019 they agreed to take concrete measures to “prepare populations for peace.” These happened against the backdrop of a substantial decline in the number of casualty-causing incidents to a handful in 2019. These developments, on the one hand, denoted the importance of political will for de-escalation and, on the other hand, generated hope and favorable conditions for further agreements and an eventual breakthrough.

These expectations, unfortunately, did not become reality, as an abrupt volte-face of Prime Minister Pashinyan caused a dramatic deterioration in the peace process and paved the way for the current escalation. Three decisive milestones can be marked in his policies that dealt serious blows to the negotiations and provoked the military confrontation.

First, in March 2019, Pashinyan and his government cast doubt on the internationally mediated negotiation process and attempted to change its format by bringing in representatives of the local regime in the occupied Karabakh region. This attempt was challenged not only by Azerbaijan but also by the OSCE’s Minsk Group. It is important to note that the founding documents of the Minsk Conference, dated March 24, 1992, defined the two parties to the negotiation - Armenia and Azerbaijan. Elected and other representatives from the Nagorno-Karabakh region of Azerbaijan will join the negotiation process only after consultation with and consent from all parties. This formula implied that, given some progress in the talks, both communities of the Nagorno-Karabakh region - Armenian and Azerbaijani - would become involved, as clarified by the Minsk Group Chairman in a statement issued on September 15, 1992.

The second destructive move was made by the Armenian Prime Minister in the summer of 2019. In his address at the opening ceremony of the Pan-Armenian games that were held illegally in Khankandi, part of the Armenian-occupied internationally recognized territories of Azerbaijan, on August 5, 2019, Pashinyan called for unification between Armenia and Karabakh, declaring “Karabakh is Armenia, period.” Breaking with the tradition of former Armenian governments that previously denied Yerevan’s control over the occupied regime established in the Nagorno-Karabakh region of Azerbaijan, he put the essence of the entire peace effort into question. Even Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov of Russia, Armenia’s ally within the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), reacted to Pashinyan’s speech and highlighted that such statements “do not help the settlement of the conflict.”

Finally, the last major blow to the peace process was dealt in April 2020, when the Armenian government denied the existence of any documents on the negotiating table. This statement was made by the Foreign Ministry of Armenia in response to the remarks of Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov about the peace negotiations between Armenia and Azerbaijan. Addressing a videoconference organized by the Gorchakov Public Diplomacy Fund, Lavrov expressed support to the existing “firmly established format of negotiations” and described the draft documents on the agenda to be a “very important step in implementing the [United Nations] Security Council resolutions.” This caused particular concern in Armenia as the resolutions of the UN Security Council, adopted in 1993, demanded the immediate withdrawal of Armenian military forces from the occupied territories of Azerbaijan. A month later, making yet another provocative move, the Armenian side held an inauguration ceremony, with Prime Minister Pashinyan present, for the new so-called president of the local regime in the city of Shusha in occupied Nagorno-Karabakh - a place of deep cultural significance to Azerbaijanis.

The July 12-14 escalation should not be viewed as unexpected against the background of this record low in relations between Armenia and Azerbaijan since mid-2018. However, the clashes between the two sides took place in an unusual location, as the bone of contention between the two conflicting parties is occupied Nagorno-Karabakh and the surrounding territories. A number of reasons have been mentioned by local and international observers attempting to explain the motivation behind this incident.

For many experts, the attack - directly along the state border between the two rival South Caucasus neighbors - was a deliberate move by the Armenian side to lay the ground for the involvement of the Moscow-led CSTO in the conflict. Notably, any hostilities in the Karabakh region itself or the surrounding Armenian-occupied areas do not fall under the jurisdiction of the alliance owing to the status of this area as part of Azerbaijan’s internationally recognized territories. In an attempt to invoke Article 4 of the CSTO Charter, which designates an attack on a member state as an attack against all members, Armenia’s Foreign Minister Zohrab Mnatsakanyan held a phone conversation with CSTO Secretary General Stanislav Zas. A few hours after their talks, the secretary general announced an emergency meeting of the organization; however, that meeting was soon postponed indefinitely, for unknown reasons.

A plan to sever the connection between Azerbaijan and Europe was also assumed by some observers as part of the motivation leading to the July clashes. Importantly, Azerbaijan’s Tovuz district where the recent clashes took place is a region that hosts major energy pipelines (the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan oil pipeline and the Southern Gas Corridor) and transportation routes (the Baku-Tbilisi-Kars railway and the East-West Transport Corridor) connecting Azerbaijan with Europe through Georgia and Turkey. Any instability in this part of Azerbaijan would deal a serious blow to its connection with its Western partners, with overarching consequences for both sides. Therefore, the potential role of some third parties, who oppose the rise of Western influence into the South Caucasus, in the recent escalation on the border has been emphasized by some experts.

The escalation, unfortunately, did not remain limited to the clashes between the armed forces, but it spiraled into information warfare between the two nations and, more dangerously, spilled over into the diasporas in third countries. Most strikingly, as part of the disinformation campaign that Armenia waged against Azerbaijan, it was claimed that “Having so many casualties without territorial gains, the Ministry of Defense of Azerbaijan threatened to launch a missile strike on the Armenian Metsamor nuclear power plant.”

This particular threat had, in fact, been made by a low-ranking official of the Ministry of Defense of Azerbaijan. However, there are two nuances that must be mentioned to get a clear understanding of the context and motives. First, the statement by the official of the Ministry of Defense was made in response to a question by a journalist who asked how Azerbaijan would reply if Armenia were to strike the Mingachevir Dam, the biggest dam in the entire Caucasus that would cause catastrophic humanitarian consequences to Azerbaijan if destroyed in a military attack. Contrary to the claims quoted above, therefore, this pronouncement was not made because of “so many casualties without territorial gains.” Second, the Presidential Administration of Azerbaijan refuted the claim that Azerbaijan has plans to strike Armenia’s nuclear plant and emphasized that this threat was made by a low-ranking official and does not represent the official policy of Azerbaijan.

The attacks against Azerbaijani civilians in third countries were of even greater concern and need to be taken seriously. One such attack occurred in Los Angeles, a Californian city that hosts the largest Armenian community outside Armenia. More than 500 Armenian protestors faced off with an Azerbaijani group of much smaller size (less than 50 people) near the Azerbaijan Consulate General. The Los Angeles Police Department is currently investigating three hate crime and battery incidents after three people from the Azerbaijani group sustained non-life-threatening injuries. For the U.S. Ambassador to Azerbaijan, Earle Litzenberger, there is irrefutable evidence that the provocation in Los Angeles was committed by aggressive Armenian demonstrators.

What is more, the recent developments between Armenia and Azerbaijan are extremely worrying as they are also an indication for future confrontations between the armed forces of the two countries and between civilians. The evident failure of the internationally mediated negotiations and the destructive dynamics in the region continue to preclude a breakthrough in the foreseeable future and keep peace as an inaccessible dream of the region’s people. This situation in the South Caucasus needs to be taken more seriously by all international organizations whose mission is to promote peace and non-violent conflict-resolution across the world as well as by all the major powers that can influence the process.”

Share news on social media

Follow us on social network

Burgas Hosts First-Ever International AI Olympiad August 9 to 15

Kyrgyz delegation visits Azerbaijan’s Electronic Security Center

IOC elects French Alps 2030 as Olympic and Paralympic Winter Games host

Azerbaijan, Colombia discuss implementation of joint projects

Bulgarian Painter Ventzislav Dikov Exhibits Works in Tokyo

President Ilham Aliyev inspected progress of Victory Park construction in Baku VIDEO

California hosts 10th International Conference on Mars

Plane crashes at airport in Nepal’s capital just after takeoff, killing 18 people and injuring pilot

Azerbaijani and Russian foreign ministries hold political consultations

The Green Energy and the Vision of President Ilham Aliyev who awaits to host COP29

® Order ABB debit cards online with SİMA KYC

® Special campaign for individual entrepreneurs seeking micro business loans from Birbank Biznes

BHOS students participate in summer school at China University of Petroleum

Azerbaijan’s Defense Minister meets with military personnel serving in liberated territories

Trash dropped by a North Korean balloon falls on South Korea’s presidential compound

Release of the Press Service of the President

Oil prices rise in global markets

Azerbaijani oil price falls in global markets

UK’s scrapped Rwanda migrant plan a ‘shocking waste’ of $904 million in public funds, minister says

China unveils rules for implementing Law on Guarding State Secrets

Moscow hosts Day of Azerbaijani Culture

18th Baku Summer Energy School, held in two countries, concludes

Mount Etna volcanic eruption closes Catania international airport

Football, rugby matches at Paris Olympics to start Wednesday

® Another update from Birbank Biznes: Order payments now available on the mobile App

To His Excellency Mr. To Lam, President of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam

AMADA implements innovative measures for Paris 2024 Summer Olympic and Paralympic Games

Azerbaijan's Central Election Commission releases “Police Officers’ Handbook” for parliamentary elections

New UNAIDS report shows AIDS pandemic can be ended by 2030, but only if leaders boost resources and protect human rights now

UN Secretary-General: ‘Renew our commitment for a future where every child is safe, free’

Musk says Tesla to use humanoid robots next year

UNESCO report: Women and girls’ access to sport still lagging far behind

Baku hosts meeting between Azerbaijani and Chinese military education experts

Azerbaijani oil price down in global markets

Forests face increasing climate-related stress amid growing demand for their products, FAO report warns

BTA, Kyrgyzstan's Kabar News Agency sign cooperation agreement

Sniper training course held in Azerbaijan Army

Serbian military attaché informed about Azerbaijan’s landmine problem

President Ilham Aliyev: We attach great importance to our traditional ties of friendship and cooperation with Egypt

Harris secures enough delegate endorsements to win Democratic presidential nomination

To His Excellency Mr. Abdel Fattah El-Sisi, President of the Arab Republic of Egypt

Spokesperson for US Department of State: Armenia and Azerbaijan continue to make significant progress toward finalizing a peace agreement

Korean Air commits to up to 50 Boeing widebody airplanes

US' Blinken to head to Asia to show ‘America is all in on the Indo-Pacific’

19 cultural artifacts smuggled abroad returned to Türkiye

AZAL introduces digital ID cards for ticket purchases to Nakhchivan

COP29 CEO: Creation of green corridors is of great importance for Azerbaijan

Second Global Media Forum themed “Unmasking False Narratives: Confronting Disinformation” wraps up in Shusha

Participants of Second Shusha Global Media Forum visit Lachin

Foreign Ministry: EU’s decision to send military aid to Armenia is an erroneous and dangerous step

® Azercell congratulates media workers on National Press and Journalism Day

Second Shusha Global Media Forum features presentation of report highlighting French colonialism

UEFA Champions League 3rd qualifying round draw held

CEC Chairman: 480 local observers registered for parliamentary elections so far

LeBron James named USA men's flagbearer at Paris 2024 Opening Ceremony

Neftchi Baku sign German defender

Delegation from Belarusian State University of Informatics and Radioelectronics visits Baku Higher Oil School

AZERTAC employees visit grave of National Leader Heydar Aliyev in Alley of Honors

ANAMA: 1673.7 hectares of territory cleared of mines and UXOs over past week

Azerbaijani military pilots conduct training flights

Shusha-hosted Global Media Forum features panel session on AI’s impact on reality, media and disinformation

China to allow delayed retirement to combat population woes

Shusha hosts presentation on “Solidarity for the Green World – COP29”

China hosts 8th Ministerial on Climate Action

4.9 magnitude earthquake jolts Georgia

AZERTAC and Vietnam's VNA to renew cooperation agreement VIDEO

AZERTAC signs cooperation agreements with four foreign news agencies at Shusha Global Media Forum VIDEO

Oil prices rise in global markets

Biden says will not seek reelection as US president

West preparing for direct military conflict with Russia — Vucic

Second Shusha Global Media Forum discusses ways of building more resilient societies against disinformation

Global Media Forum participants tour Shusha

President Ilham Aliyev shares post on National Press Day

Executive Committee of the Turkish News Agencies Alliance holds its 1st meeting in Shusha

Second Shusha Global Media Forum discusses mapping the reach of disinformation

Problem of fake news manifests itself in the easiest and fastest forms thanks to technological development

Vugar Aliyev: ATNA should play the role of an institution where news of the Turkic world is collected

Mikhail Gusman: Information warfare is a global phenomenon ındependent of political regimes

Azerbaijan Army positions in Kalbajar direction were subjected to fire

Assistant to the President: Sharing accurate information is crucial for society

Hikmet Hajiyev: We faced a powerful disinformation campaign regarding COP29

Hikmet Hajiyev: Disinformation turned into psychological warfare against the Azerbaijani people VIDEO

Shusha hosted second Global Media Forum
President Ilham Aliyev attended the Forum VIDEO

President: We always feel brotherly support from Pakistani media

President: We could have waited 17 more years if necessary for liberation of our lands

President of Azerbaijan: We are very actively trying to activate our cooperation with members of African Union

President Ilham Aliyev: Our target is to double supply of Azerbaijani gas to Europe

President of Azerbaijan: For the sake of peace and the liberation of our territories, I had to set aside all my feelings and all my emotions

President Ilham Aliyev: I hope that after elections there will be more understanding in Washington and Europe about Azerbaijan

Reception was held in honor of participants of second Shusha Global Media Forum

Azerbaijani army personnel involved in “Birlestik-2024” exercise return to motherland, Defense Ministry

Azerbaijan Chess Federation and FIDE discuss future prospects of cooperation

President of Azerbaijan: All the leaders in UK were asking about Armenia and the peace treaty

Azerbaijani President: Our relations with the United States were pretty stable

President Ilham Aliyev: Prime Minister Pashinyan refused to meet with me in the U.K.

President of Azerbaijan: There is a progress in process of normalization of relations with Armenia VIDEO

President Ilham Aliyev: We now actively work with developing countries in order to build bridges between Global South and Global North

President of Azerbaijan: Our COP Team is working very efficiently

Arab News: In run-up to major event, COP29, host nation Azerbaijan has been working hard to achieve its green development goals

President of Azerbaijan: Some countries still suffer from colonialism, and we want to help them