The Azerbaijan State News Agency

POLITICS

The Hill issues article on slaughter of Azerbaijanis in Guba and Khojali

Washington, April 25 (AZERTAC). The US newspaper The Hill has issued an article headlined “The language of genocide” by Mallory Moss.

“According to Encyclopedia Brittanica, the term “ethnic cleansing” comes from a literal translation of the same words in Serbo-Croatian and was used in conjunction with the massacres of ethnic groups in Bosnia Herzegovina, Croatia, and East Timor during the 1990s. Encyclopedia Brittanica also points out that the phrase is controversial, not for its connotation, but for the question of whether or not it is the same as genocide. Using “ethnic cleansing” to discuss ethnocide is tantamount to using the phrase “Final Solution” to discuss the Holocaust. Murder is murder; there is nothing pure about it. I have knowingly walked along two sites of mass death: once when I was “touring” the barracks at Dachau; the other when I was in Guba, Azerbaijan, and within inches of the skeletal remains of children. Neither time did it occur to me to define whether these were results of genocide, ethnocide, massacre, or pogrom. I was faced with horror and as a result was sorrowful - a human response to inhuman circumstances.

When I investigated the circumstances of the mandibles, femurs, and tiny skulls amassed before me, again I was confronted with a linguistic battlefield. Azeris have termed the eradication of their villages during the 20th Century as genocide perpetrated by the Armenians (with the periodic assistance of the Russians). Opponents disagree and have labeled these events as “tragedies.” So let’s look at definitions with the help of Merriam-Webster. Tragedy is defined as “a very bad event that causes great sadness.” To call a mass murder a “tragedy” is demeaning and seems to be bereft of the value of life.

On February 25th and 26th of 1992, shortly after Azerbaijan became an independent republic, Armenian forces captured the airport city of Khojaly and instead of allowing the citizens to flee, they chose to murder them instead. I discuss these two February days because what happened is hotly contested. What is not under debate was that 613 civilians were murdered (including 106 women and 63 children) but instead it is the terminology that has caused offense. The Armenians hotly contest that these murders were not a genocide and instead caused by the Azeri soldiers attempting to camouflage among the “complicit citizens.” Even if true, and its veracity is questionable, is this not the same as stating that the fleeing captives at the Nazi death camp Sobibor were responsible for those shot along the fence during their escape? Were the Bielski brothers the cause of Jewish deaths in the forests of Poland or were they responsible for one of the greatest rescues of Jews from a Nazi-occupied country?

So confused was I about terms at this point, I decided to create a murder flowchart. Is the killing deliberate? If so, it is murder. Are more than three people murdered? Then, according to the FBI, it is a mass murder. Now the numbers get vague. There does not seem to be a specific value that changes a mass murder into a massacre. However there are various qualifiers that identify a massacre: “atrocious, cruel, unnecessary, and indiscriminate.”

Yes, you read the first three adjectives correctly. Perhaps it is my bleeding heart at play, but I have been wracking my brain to come up with a multiple murder that is not “atrocious, cruel and unnecessary” and have failed miserably. Indiscriminate is really the only adjective with a substantial indication. Were the killings in Khojaly indiscriminate? The murderers shot into crowds of fleeing families, so yes, the criterion seems met.

Once we add the context of race and ethnicity into the various definitions of murder, the door to more dramatic definitions opens. Merriam-Webster defines genocide as the killing of people that are part of a political, cultural, or racial group. This seems to be the most open and straightforward definition of genocide. Encyclopedia Brittanica’s definition requires the murders to be systematic to be labeled genocide. A pogrom requires organized killing of helpless people, usually because of race or religion. And “ethnic cleansing” doesn’t necessarily require murder (it can be “removal”) but for those displaced it is likely tantamount to both.

Now, with all that said, does any of it matter? Not a bit. For who decides whether a group of killings is systematic or organized? Does there have to be a game plan or is the indiscriminate slaughter of people based on race, religion, or culture “good enough” to count as genocide? Once again we are brought to the morbid juxtaposition of the linguistics of death. Are there people counting bodies, verifying premeditation, and checking levels of systematization of murder? Or are there politically based lobbies that push for one set of murders to be demoted to tragedy when, in fact, so much more.

I know the bones that I saw in Guba were not those from Khojaly, just as I know they weren’t from any other graveyard in the world. But the skeletons in Guba, with their unnatural weaving of limbs, reached out to me and represented the children of genocide everywhere - Babi Yar, Rwanda and the Trail of Tears - and frankly at that point, semantics didn’t mean a damn thing.

So what “-cide” are you on? Do the bodies of 169 women and children rate high enough in your book to be a genocide? My mandate to those people vehemently arguing terms: stop counting corpses. Look instead to the intent of those that are shooting the bullets, cleaving the limbs, or starving the children. Were the victims murdered because they were Tutsi, Jewish, Muslim, Mormon, or any other religion or ethnicity distasteful to the ruling or invading party? Were the victims transported in cattle cars or forced to walk thousands of miles for relocation? This is not “cleansing” or “removal.” This is eradication based on culture, ethnicity and/or religion. This is genocide,” the article says.

Mallory Moss is a noted commentator and writer on humans and humanity. Moss received her doctorate at the University of Colorado and is a Board Certified Nurse Practitioner of Psychiatry. She is also a clinical nurse specialist in psychiatric nursing and received her Master of Science (MSN) at the University of Colorado and Bachelor Degree in psychology at UCLA. She currently serves at Colorado’s prestigious AspenPointe.

The full text of the article is available at http://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/204175-the-language-of-genocide.

Share news on social media

Follow us on social network

Azerbaijani junior weightlifter snatches three golds in European Championships

Azerbaijan chovgan team becomes world champion

Azerbaijan Army positions in Nakhchivan direction were once again subjected to fire

Event held on anniversary of Military Publishing House

Release of the Press Service of the President

First Vice-President Mehriban Aliyeva shared post on Eid al-Adha

GUAM countries discussed enhancing cooperation in transportation and communication sectors

President of BRISD and Global Climate Youth Leader, participates in UNFCCC SB60 in Bonn

Spain defeat Croatia 3-0 in Group B game at EURO 2024

President of Northern Cyprus Ersin Tatar congratulates Azerbaijan on National Salvation Day and 3rd anniversary of Shusha Declaration

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan congratulates people of Azerbaijan on National Salvation Day

President Ilham Aliyev shared post on Eid al-Adha

Azerbaijan Army holds series of events on National Salvation Day

Shusha-hosted conference features panel session on "Turkic World-2040: a conceptual vision of the future"

Switzerland beat Hungary 3-1 in Group A match of EURO 2024

Shusha hosts discussions on party diplomacy as a new dialogue platform

Turkish ministers congratulate leadership and people of Azerbaijan on National Salvation Day

Doncic scores 29, Mavericks roll past Celtics 122-84 to avoid a sweep in NBA Finals

Chinese military delegation continues visit to Azerbaijan

Turkish Foreign Ministry: We will be together forever as "One nation, two states"

Earth's climate might have been influenced by sun's passage through dense interstellar cloud: Study

Azerbaijani Premier and Speaker of Milli Majlis visit grave of National Leader Heydar Aliyev in Alley of Honors

Azerbaijan's defense ministry organizes media tour to Military Trophy Park VIDEO

Shusha hosts discussions on regional contribution of Organization of Turkic States to global security

National Leader Heydar Aliyev's services in Turkic world are remembered today with great appreciation, says Deputy Chairman of New Azerbaijan Party

Title holders Italy to play Albania in their EURO 2024 group opener on Saturday

First Vice-President Mehriban Aliyeva made post on occasion of June 15 - National Salvation Day

Shusha hosts conference on “Organization of Turkic States: towards new strategic goals in context of geopolitical realities and global cataclysms"

Azerbaijani President: Relations between countries of Organization of Turkic States represent a very important factor for stability, security and development

To His Majesty Charles III, King of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland

President Ilham Aliyev: Cooperation among political parties of countries of Organization of Turkic States plays an important role in realization of common goals

Pope warns of potential dangers from AI

To the participants of the international conference on “Organization of Turkic States: towards new strategic goals in the context of geopolitical realities and global cataclysms”

Hosts Germany beat 10-man Scotland 5 - 1 in UEFA EURO 2024 opener

President Ilham Aliyev made post on June 15 - National Salvation Day

COP29 Chief Executive Officer meets with EU Ambassador to Azerbaijan

IOC EB proposes creation of “Olympic Esports Games” to IOC Session

Azerbaijani rower ranks 3rd in BRICS Sports Games Kazan 2024

Azerbaijan Army positions in Nakhchivan direction once again subjected to fire

Baku hosts event on climate change and its impact on population dynamics as part of the "29 Climate Conversations: The Road to COP29" series

Azerbaijan 3x3 basketball team ready for action in FIBA Women’s Series Clermont-Ferrand Stop 2024

Azerbaijan Army’s Chief of General Staff watches tactical-special exercise of engineering units

"Azerkhalcha" OJSC and Aydan Salahova signed a joint project - "Woman" triptych carpet

From Daniel Noboa Azín, Constitutional President of the Republic of Ecuador

Azerbaijani, Bangladesh’s foreign ministries hold political consultations

From Dr Mohamed Irfaan Ali, President of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana

Awareness-raising event on “State guarantees for rights and freedoms of persons with disabilities” arranged as part of Human Rights Month

Azerbaijan, Serbia discuss military cooperation

Coastal Cleanup Initiative organized with COP29 volunteers

From Abdullatif Jamal Rashid, President of the Republic of Iraq

Astana hosts meeting on COP29 preparations

ASCO orders BS new vessels

Azerbaijan exports crude oil and oil products worth $6.258 billion in January-May 2024

AZPROMO, "Enterprise Greece" ink Memorandum of Understanding

4 forest officials killed while extinguishing fire in India's Uttarakhand

Azerbaijani sambo fighter grabs bronze in BRICS Sports Games Kazan 2024

Germany eyes boost in tourism revenue during UEFA Euro 2024

Why is Germany opposed to EU tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles?

Gender equality linked to men eating more meat

Ambassador of Brazil visits Baku Higher Oil School

Storied Titian painting found at London bus stop after theft goes to auction

SOCAR, Baker Hughes sign Cooperation Agreement

Coca-Cola files applications to register 8 trademarks in Russia

Solar energy production in Azerbaijan increased 8 times

UNEC in "THE Impact 2024" ranking

President Ilham Aliyev congratulates people of Azerbaijan on Eid al-Adha

Azerbaijan’s Defense Minister meets with Chinese military delegation

Moscow to host 102nd meeting of CIS Economic Council

Message of congratulation to the people of Azerbaijan on the occasion of Eid al-Adha

COP29 Presidency launches COP29 Academy

S. Korea, U.S., Japan expected to hold 1st trilateral multidomain exercise late June

® Winners of “AZERCELL CUP 2024” competition announced

5,000 sturgeons released into Caspian Sea as part of CANSO event

® Kapital Bank offers advantageous options to customers with cash loans and credit cards from other banks

June 14 marks World Blood Donor Day

Oil prices down in world markets

Azerbaijani oil price rises in global markets

Azerbaijan Army positions in Nakhchivan direction once again subjected to fire

Assistant to the President Hikmet Hajiyev participates in political dialogue in "NATO + Azerbaijan" format in Brussels and conducts several meetings

Hybrid-format event on decolonization and role of communication held

Azerbaijani wrestlers ready for action in Poland

Baku Initiative Group to continue supporting Kanak people's struggle for independence

ACLU, immigrant rights groups sue to stop Biden border policy

Czech ambassador to Azerbaijan informed about preparations for COP29

NATO's Mobile Training Team conducts course at Azerbaijan Air Force

Italy's premier kicks off G7 summit to discuss global issues, Ukraine, Mideast

AFFA president meets with Fernando Santos

® Kapital Bank participates in Nakhchivan’s first “Career Fair”

Azerbaijani female chess player wins bronze at FIDE World Junior Chess Championships U20

® Silk Way West Airlines successfully transported yaks from Kyrgyzstan to Azerbaijan

Acropolis in Athens closed as Greece bakes in heatwave: What travellers need to know

More than 5,000 migrants killed on perilous journey from North Africa to Spanish coast in January-May 2024

Ombudsperson comments on French government’s biased position against Azerbaijani media representative

At least 40 Indians die in a fire at a building housing foreign workers in Kuwait

England's hospital waiting lists rise to 7.57m

AZANS, Aireon and Metron Aviation collaborate for advanced digital platforms in civil aviation

Paulo Fonseca named AC Milan coach and tasked with challenging Serie A champ Inter

Azerbaijani parliamentary delegation visits National Library of Belarus

Maire representatives visit Baku Higher Oil School

AI must never stand for 'advancing inequality,' says UN chief